Bizarre Butt Plugs
This is our collection of some of our most unique, popular and inspiring butt plugs. From our popular and unique Anal Intruder Cock Ring to our classic anal plug animal tail favorites like our fox tail butt plug, our selection features high-quality products to make your fetish fantasies come to life. If you just want to dress up extra-special, pucker up with one of our beautiful pieces of anal jewelry such as our flower anal plug.
Filter by
64 products
Filter and sort
Closer filter drawer
64 products
Hosed 1.5 Inch Beaded Anal Snake
$54.95
$34.95
You save $20.00 (36% OFF)
Sinister Eye Metal Butt Plug
$14.95
$9.95
You save $5.00 (33% OFF)
Midnight Fox Glass Butt Plug with Tail
$43.95
$26.95
You save $17.00 (39% OFF)
Cosmo Hound Silicone Butt Plug
$34.95
$24.95
You save $10.00 (29% OFF)
Tom of Finland Weighted Anal Beads
$94.95
$62.95
You save $32.00 (34% OFF)
Grey Wolf Tail Anal Plug and Ears Set
$60.95
$39.95
You save $21.00 (34% OFF)
Pink Heart Anal Plug Set
$49.95
$29.99
You save $19.96 (40% OFF)
Octo-Squirm Vibrating & Squirming Silicone Anal Plug
$99.95
$74.95
You save $25.00 (25% OFF)
Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug
$30.95
$18.99
You save $11.96 (39% OFF)
Black Heart Gem Anal Plug
$19.95
$12.95
You save $7.00 (35% OFF)
Remote Control Wagging Fox Tail Anal Plug
$125.95
$59.99
You save $65.96 (52% OFF)
Knuckles Small Clenched Fist Dildo
$53.95
$33.99
You save $19.96 (37% OFF)
Extra 25% Off with code: DISCIPLINE
Octo-Twist Silicone Anal Plug
$34.95
$24.95
You save $10.00 (29% OFF)
White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug
$30.95
$18.99
You save $11.96 (39% OFF)
Vibrating White Fox Tail Slender Anal Plug
$74.95
$49.95
You save $25.00 (33% OFF)
Double Ball Plug with Sliding O-Ring Rod
$184.95
$98.00
You save $86.95 (47% OFF)
Extra 25% Off with code: DISCIPLINE
Rainbow Prism Heart Anal Plug
$19.95
$11.95
You save $8.00 (40% OFF)
Stretch Master 2 Piece Training Silicone Ass Grommet Set
$35.95
$19.95
You save $16.00 (45% OFF)
Extra 25% Off with code: DISCIPLINE
The Earl Cock and Ball Ring with Anal Plug
$20.95
$12.95
You save $8.00 (38% OFF)
Hosed 2 inch Beaded Anal Snake
$81.95
$50.95
You save $31.00 (38% OFF)
Devil Tail Anal Plug and Horns Set
$55.95
$37.95
You save $18.00 (32% OFF)
Bunny Tail Anal Plug and Mask Set
$78.95
$44.95
You save $34.00 (43% OFF)
Blondie Pony Tail Butt Plug
$32.95
$21.95
You save $11.00 (33% OFF)
Volkron Silicone Anal Plug
$35.95
$26.95
You save $9.00 (25% OFF)
Filter by
64 products
Filter and sort
Closer filter drawer
64 products
Fox Tail Glass Anal Plug
$45.95
$26.95
You save $19.00 (41% OFF)
Woof XL Silicone Puppy Tail Butt Plug
$62.95
$38.95
You save $24.00 (38% OFF)
Extra 25% Off with code: DISCIPLINE
Onyx Bunny Tail Anal Plug
$30.95
$18.99
You save $11.96 (39% OFF)
Dragonspawn Silicone Butt Plug
$29.95
$19.95
You save $10.00 (33% OFF)
Light Up Silicone Anal Plug
$24.95
$14.95
You save $10.00 (40% OFF)
Rainbow Unicorn Tail Anal Plug
$39.95
$27.95
You save $12.00 (30% OFF)
Flower Hearts Anal Plug Set
$69.95
$39.95
You save $30.00 (43% OFF)
Eye of the Dragon Silicone Butt Plug
$34.95
$24.95
You save $10.00 (29% OFF)
Fox Tail Butt Plug
$53.95
$39.95
You save $14.00 (26% OFF)
White Fox Tail Anal Plug and Ears Set
$60.95
$39.95
You save $21.00 (34% OFF)
Rainbow Pony Tail Anal Plug
$42.95
$28.95
You save $14.00 (33% OFF)
Booty Bloom Silicone Rose Anal Plug
$34.95
$19.95
You save $15.00 (43% OFF)
Extra 25% Off with code: DISCIPLINE
Bunny Tail Anal Plug
$26.95
$14.99
You save $11.96 (44% OFF)
Sold out
Kraken Glow-in-the-Dark Silicone Anal Plug
$34.95
$24.95
You save $10.00 (29% OFF)